First time i was sly, I had a headblade classic. after 2 years, i decided to go back the the fuzzy head crowd. The HB was still alive and kicking.
Last May I went back to the sly ways with a HB sport. I replace the adapters every 3 months. I've actually noticed that even if the adapter still holds the blades, I get a closer shave with a fresh adapter.
BTW, I use sensor blades with my HB, so i don't know if the astra adapters last longer or not.