Just remember, it takes at least three months to see what you've got. Since you've already gotten compliments, I think you're really going to like it at three months. It won't be a "mature" beard until about 8 to 12 months as dormant hairs start coming into play and thicken it even more.
You look awesome either way......but my personal preference is with the beard! Makes you look hard!
definitly stay bearded man!