It really depends on what you like. I actually alternate between Glossy and Matte.
I also get a great natural shine after using witch hazel too.
Shiny is the way to go! I have been looking for the "best" way to achieve this. I will try the Nivea and the shaving oil. Would Warhawk's "Shave Secret" work as well as the King of Shaves Oil?
Count my vote for SHINE. I like high gloss.
Definitely shiny! I uncovered my dome for a reason and I want my slyness to shine in all it's glory!
Shiny!!!!!!
Why cover up all that beauy?
SHINY brother, shiny!

Heck even my newly skinned flattie...
gots to shine!

Shiny for sure. I find that all I need to do is work a drop (literally one small drop) of Baby Oil with Vitamin E and work it in, followed by a splash of witch hazel or rubbing alcohol for a supreme shine.
I try to get mine as shiny as possible...