Son, it basically comes down to preference.
I have both, and I usually switch off between them and BG'z moisture gel. They all work well for me.
I love the Headlube Glossy, makes it easier to be seen in a crowd!
SLICK SHANE...by the way....Nice Pic....very cool...
I just use natural aloe vera gel....seems to give me a nice shine that isnt overly glossy.
Glossy. The glossier the better.
Matte. My head gets shiny as the day goes on.
I like the matte look myself.
Another vote for matte, here.