I have a very similar routine, with the exception of the electric shaver. I shave in the shower using a Fusion ProGlide. I also use the Aveeno shave cream. However, be careful which Aveeno you use, they have three of them. You should use Aveeno Positively Smooth Shave Gel. That's the one with the light blue cap. Sometimes this is found in the women's shaving product instead of the men's. Add a few drops of Shave Secret shaving oil and you'll get a slick smooth shave.I also apply the Aveeno After Shave Lotion and it does feel good on the head. In the beginning I was a little self conscious of the shine, but I got over it. I don't mind the slick shiny head.