Welcome, Andrew! It so happens that I own a straight razor as well as a DE. I only got into DE shaving last year thanks to a couple of friends, but I've had my straight razor since 2010. Personally, both can give you a very good shave, but given the sharpness of both, I wouldn't use either on days that you need a quick shave (the Head Blade products are the best if you are in a hurry). Straight razor and DE shaves are relaxing, however, you need to commit some time if using either. Good luck!
Welcome Andrew!I can tell you that I also own a straight blade, the thing is it is EXCEEDINGLY sharp. I tried a little area to test and got 4 blood spots. Someone else on SBG had said they would not try it on the scalp, although some barbers will do this.I would be afraid of looking like a medical experiment when I was done. I like the HeadBlade but I have not gotten a real close shave with mine, for some reason. I need to go online and watch some vids and see if I can figure it out. I agree with Tyler though, it's not a gimmick. Your shave routine sounds excellent, though. I like how you do it. Do you use a brush? That helps me A LOT. I get flakes around my eyebrows and used to on my scalp, but since shaving and using lotion they are gone. I'm thinking maybe I should shave my eyebrows too... Good luck and keep posting!
Wow, Andrew! And I was pissed when I took a chunk out of my goatee and had to shave it off! I can't imagine what shaving off your eye brows is like. You are a brave man and must have a lot of confidence!