Hard to say...especially since I've been using shave secret combined with either Bald Guyz gel or Headslick or the shaving soap that came with my shaving brush....My answer is ever since I've been using a shaving brush, the cream or gel really doesn't matter. I say get a shaving brush for better results.
Mr Cain09, its hard to say, since I use the old "Wet Shaving" gear which is in my opinion a closer and more satisfying shave than with the gels and or canned creams.
I've use edge before it works pretty good have not tried gillette yet but sahve gel by schick works well if your into the gels that come in a can the edge that comes in a tube works well also go check out target next time your there
Mr.C-
There are better products than those two for not a lot more cash. Check out some shave Creams ... you may be pleasantly surprised.