It's what you like, not what we like. Both looks are fine, depending on the way they strike you. If you like it, we'll like it! Come on, wavering sly guys! This site all about supporting the sly look. Nobody should need affirmation from the rest of us over their choices.*
*Well, comb-overs and plugs and rugs might get some flak, yet if you are participating here, you probably know the downsides of all of those. But goat or not? Look in the mirror and ask yourself (quietly--you don't need eavesdroppers), "Do I like this?" If you do... game over. "Move along folks. Nothing to see here."