I tried a brand named Van Der Hagen shave soap. I read about that in here a few years ago. WalMart used to carry them and I have also seen then at Walgreen's. They make a 40% moisturizer soap and also a glycerin soap which, in my opinion is THE bomb.
Van Der Hagen is made in the USA, as well, which made me feel better. I think it was the only thing WalMart sold that wasn't made in China.