Is it oil control you are going for or the matte finish?
Have you tried the Matte for Men, or the matte finish Headlube? My MFM should be coming this week. I don't really have a problem with oil, but I want to reduce the mirror effect and even out the skin tone with the Matte for Men supposedly does. I am highly prone to freckling.
And remember that some oil is good. Keeps the skin from drying out and flaking.
My skin is very oily so nothing I use really helps control oil. By mid-day I'm an oil slick. However, this week I tried not putting any moisturizer of any kind on my head. After my shave I just use Head Clear and nothing else. I made it further through the day before the oiliness got really bad. I think if you got oily skin you really don't need a moisturizer...you got natural moisturizer.
I agree with you 100% ycartt! BUT, if I don't use anything for a few days I do still end up with flaking! Fine line between too oily and too dry.
I use Jack Black oil control lotion ... I tried the others and nothing kept my head oil free ... this stuff works awesome. Downside? It's pricey, about $17 ... you can get it at Nordstrom's or Sephora.
In the interest of helping others, do you feel that the various wipe products help with oil control? I am often shocked at the amount of dirt and oil they remove in the afternoons when I use them.
The baldguyz headwipes are excellent for a quick refreshing.
I think I might just stick with the headlube matte. Alot of great stuff here guys.