Hey my brother, just go for it. Now.... i'll wait.... no really..............OK! Yes, you will have the two tone look for a while. But like Mike said, get some of the Jergens Sunless Tan Stuff... (Actually, it is called Natural Glow) I am pretty pale complected like yourself, so go for the medium one. The one I use shows results in 3 applications. I can see it in one! Do it........ I am still waiting! lol