doug.....i get that same reaction with the witch hazel but "the burn"/tingling sensation disappears quickly. it only last for about 5 seconds. WARHAWK
It may be a personnal sensitivity to the products, Doug. I have felt a slight tingling with Clearhead, but never with HeadLube or the Headwipes. Try a refrigerated aloe vera or BaldGuyz Moisturizing gel as an alternative.