That's part of the fun of being a headshaver, trying different soaps, razor, blades, and lotions.
Everyone develops their own routine that works for them. When I shave after a shower with my DE razor, I use Vander Haagen soap and brush. When I shave in the shower with a Schick Extreme 3, I use Cremo and Dial coconut water soap.
After, cold water rinse, witch hazel, and Afta after shave lotion. Shines like chrome!