I wrote this long detailed response and my ipod crashed again like it always does lately (seems like apple products have gone in the toilet since a certain someone passed away) so you are now getting the quick and dirty:
Headslick, about $8 per bottle (walgreens or headblade directly. They also have small sample bottles.)
Cremo, about $6 per tube (walmart. Ultra super concentrated so it lasts forever. Have original, cooling, and mango)
There also are beebald products and another competitor I can't think of but I don't have experience with them.
Unless you are really on a budget preventing you from "playing" please go out and try barbasol aloe. I know you specified no can but this stuff is honestly amazing and that is coming from a traditional wet shaver. Runs you less then $2 a can that last over 2 months of daily use plus if you don't like it I'm sure your significant other, friend, or family member will use it. It's available everywhere, consistent, classic, and about as cheap as you can get. Just try it...