As an pwner owner of both, I can proudly say I am happy with both. For me it's a matter of how much time I want to devote to that day's headshave. If time is limited, I use the ATX and can be done within 15 minutes. If I want to devote more time for a relaxing shave (shaving until I get the BBS feel I seek) I use the DE, because I don't recommend going fast with a DE razor as you may cut yourself.