You look absolutely FINE, the look suits you!
You look good either way, so it really is a matter of personal opinion and choice.
Shawn, nice to see before and after photos. IMO the short haircut is great, you did good buzzing your hair. Thinking on going even shorter?
Regardless of what you do, I hope you will continue to participate here. Great guys with good information. We've had several fellows with BDD as well, so it's not an unknown issue around here.