I tried Neutrogena shave cream by accident - beginning three weeks ago. Electric razors burn my scalp for some reason, leaving me sore, so I went back to my Headblade and needed some gel.
The store didn't have my normal head slick stuff, so I grabbed this, figuring that if I didn't like it, it would at least bridge the time until I could get what I wanted. Turns out I love it.
I now use this on my head and face. It's so much smoother than foam and less messy than gel. It leaves my scalp soft and feeling good. Of course, I follow with a good rinse and witchhazel as learned on these forums.
I'll give it another few months and see how things go. So far so good. Oh, and Neutrogena makes one for sensitive skin, too.