Hey all, for what it's worth, I decided to try the Gillette Proglide (manual) this week. My experience has been pretty much the opposite as what I'm reading on the SBG forums. With the help of BG Gel, I've had the quickest and most comfortable shave to date. I've also been able to shave more than 2 days in a row without irritation. I give this one a thumbs up, but that's my 2 cents.
Oh! and the Gillette Thermal Scrub is pretty awesome too...(another 2 cents)...