Is it oil control you are going for or the matte finish?
Have you tried the Matte for Men, or the matte finish Headlube? My MFM should be coming this week. I don't really have a problem with oil, but I want to reduce the mirror effect and even out the skin tone with the Matte for Men supposedly does. I am highly prone to freckling.
And remember that some oil is good. Keeps the skin from drying out and flaking.