Been reading about this concoction for quite awhile. Finally ran out of the after shave balm I'd been using. I mixed 1/2 witch hazel with 1/2 Aloe Vera Gel that already has tea tree oil as well as lidocane in the mixture. It's marketed for sun burns but I'm thinking this will work. I had an old pump bottle leftover from when I used to buy commercial massage oil. These days I use 100% pure grape seed oil for massaging and my clients love it and it's literally half the price.
